Daddy Bush for President!
Ok – maybe it didn’t go quite like that. However, the ad was essentially aiming at three of those words in its goal of persuading many of the voters of their decision to make. This ad was directed to those voters who had never managed to hear of George H. W. Bush and who perhaps had never taken their voting seriously. The ad is not overt or subversive enough to really persuade any one set in a strong Democratic opinion, but did do a good job in tipping those that had perhaps never leaned before.
The entire ad has a very familiar feel to it. The use of his wife in the ad to speak of how perhaps he is no one of great means or power convinces us that he is a believable guy. She relates that when someone doubted if he had enough pull to force his presidency that he did not worry about that but instead simply confided in good old Americans to do the right thing. Perhaps his thousands of friends could each convince ten thousand of their friends that He was a good home grown candidate. After all, he has a cookout with his grandkids – Americana at its finest. The ad paints him as in fact a good Daddy to all. To me in fact the opening 5 seconds showing everyone around him in light colors suggests that spending time with him will make you more pure. It portrays almost as a good shepherd of good people.
There is also an appeal made to see him as “everyone sees him.” The musical elements and showing him simply “acting natural” (which is a strange oxymoron to me) in a variety of situations tries to help us feel that we know him. There probably were tens of millions of potential voters that really had never heard of Bush, or had had no idea who he really was. The appeal to us to just get to know him stirs in the viewer a desire to want to know him for them self. Maybe the ad ran primarily on the Hallmark channel. We must come to know Bush, feel that we have seen his closet, and discovered it skeleton free. Only then could these viewers feel that they know who Bush is. If they have not firmly settled their minds as to who he is, considering whether or not he would make a good President is simply out of the question.
The last part of the ad seeks to build his credibility as a candidate for president. And why shouldn’t he be President? For more than 40 years he has met every challenge that the world has given him. While I see where the ad wants to go with this final point – not only is Bush a great Daddy, but he would be a great President- I feel that they do not influence the audience quite as much in this one. If I am a relatively uninformed or unbiased voter, simply seeing footage of him at press conferences will not suffice to sway me. If I were to hear that no one in this century is better prepared I would stop my emotions from begin taken any further with the music. I think that perhaps in this ad it would be better not to make the point than solely to make it halfway. They quickly return to him as a father figure, which is like throwing in the towel saying, “Yeah, we’re not exactly sure on the specifics of his potential presidency either.”
Overall the ad strikes me as just that, an advertisement. As a piece of rhetoric it could have developed itself more. I will admit that 60 seconds isn’t time to do much more than a tug a heart string or two – but it is my opinion regarding this particular spot that they should have only done that. Focusing their message more on their audience and playing to their largest strength could have helped them not just to lean a voter, but to tip them over.
Daddy Bush for President!
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment